The Balance of Justice

September 12, 2018 @ 7:00 pm – 9:00 pm

Author Eileen Hopsicker will give a book talk and signing about the Utica Streetcar Murder of 1872.

In January of 1872, Josephine McCarty was indicted for murder in a shooting on a horse-drawn street car in Utica, New York. There were witnesses, and the common consensus was that she would hang. Then the governor of New York called a special term of court, and his attorney general sent a high-powered lawyer to aid the prosecution. Why? Perhaps the story was more complex than it appeared. This accounting of Josephine’s life offers a window into another place in time, an era when flamboyant architecture and white-gloved manners masked a darker side of society. The facts brought forth in her trial reveal a woman of unfathomable courage struggling in a time when money and influence obliterated the line between villain and victim.


Leave a Reply